DAILY DEVOTIONS, LIFELONG FAITH

New Age Influences in Healthcare: A Catholic Concern

The purpose of this article is to illuminate New Age and occult influences I have encountered within certain areas of the helping professions. In so doing, I have the following goals: (a) heighten Catholic awareness; (b) explain the dangers of each identified part; and (c) provide instructions for collaborating with your clergy as you seek appropriate healthcare.

Heightening Awareness

I sat with my nine-year-old granddaughter this morning at a gathering of children for a party. I saw innocent little ones dressed for the occasion and smiling and having fun. What a gift from God to have children and grandchildren. Moreover, what a tremendous responsibility it is to take proper care of them.

This brought me to a recent interaction with a professional helper, whom I respect. We were discussing my granddaughterโ€™s care when she related one facet to signs of the zodiac. I just nodded silently and did not follow up. The helper related this information with such matter-of-factness it led me to recall my past three decades in the helping field.

During those years I interacted with professionals in medical, mental health, physical, and occupational healthcare. I encountered a surprising number of practitioners who embraced New Age spirituality, astrology, energy healing concepts, and various Eastern religious ideas.

This practitioner mentioned above was not referencing the daily horoscope in the local newspaper. Rather, she referenced โ€œnatal astrology,โ€ an ancient form of divination that has been widely incorporated into modern New Age spirituality. This system interprets a personโ€™s personality, life events, and relationships through positions of the celestial bodies at the moment of their birth. Practitioners often discuss birth charts, planetary alignments, and events of โ€œretrogradeโ€ motion as having importance for human behavior and destiny. The Catholic Church has condemned these practices (CCC 2115โ€“2117).

I have been teaching graduate counseling courses for over twenty years, ten at a state university. These students appear to have a heart for helping others. Moreover, they appear eager to learn all they can to assist with becoming not just effective, but โ€œhealers.โ€ During classroom discussions, I have noticed the infusion of New Age spirituality and various Eastern religious ideas. They embrace yogic practices, mystical meditation, tarot card readings, natal astrology, Reiki, and other energy healing concepts. Moreover, they promote these activities to clients and colleagues. Such recommendations can carry considerable influence as they come from people perceived as helpers in training.

Explaining the Dangers

When people take their children or family members to professional helpers, this is usually a time of confusion and vulnerability, and they need help developing a strategy to address the issue. Not everyone is familiar with the field of mental health and the number of different helping professionals. Unless a person has extensive experience in the field, they will not know the difference between a social worker, psychologist, or therapist. Additionally, my experience with clergy is that they often simply do not have Catholic resources for referral, so they must trust that the system monitors itself to prevent harmful practitioners from harming their parishioners.

Based upon my observations in the field, many practitioners increasingly incorporate New Age spiritual ideas and energy healing concepts into their work. Therefore, we must be careful to guard our hearts from these errors. The Desert Fathers would exhort us to use nepsis (watchfulness) to prevent practices not aligned with the Catholic Church from influencing our lives.

Iโ€™ve wondered what attracts these practitioners to New Age ideas, as many of these folks are nice, warm people. The Church provides a thoughtful answer on this matter.

A Roman Curia document entitled โ€œJesus Christ the Bearer of the Water of Lifeโ€ teaches:

Whatever questions and criticisms it may attract, New Age is an attempt by people who experience the world as harsh and heartless to bring warmth to that world. As a reaction to modernity, it operates more often than not on the level of feelings, instincts and emotions. Anxiety about an apocalyptic future of economic instability, political uncertainty and climatic change plays a large part in causing people to look for an alternative, resolutely optimistic relationship to the cosmos. (Pontifical Councils for Culture and Interreligious Dialogue, Jesus Christ the Bearer of the Water of Life: A Christian Reflection on the New Age [2003], par. 2.5)

This is a powerful statement. The people I have mentioned are not maliciously interested in harming anyone. The reverse seems true. The Church suggests that many of these systems subtly repeat the serpentโ€™s age-old temptation of Genesis 3โ€”that hidden knowledge, techniques, or spiritual power can provide what ultimately comes only through communion with God.

I have received patients whose previous therapists had encouraged them to use yoga. This moves a person away from Church teaching when yoga is presented as a spiritual discipline rooted in non-Christian religious anthropology. The same is true of meditation, and other New Age practices which practitioners use to teach their patients how to manage their anxiety, stress, and other dysregulation issues. Yet several patients reported that these practices were associated with an increase in anxiety rather than relief. A likely cause of this increase is addressed in the Curia document.

In โ€œJesus Christ the Bearerโ€ฆโ€ (par. 6.1), they note that the New Age spirituality is openly anti-Christian and creates confusion. This confusion has revealed itself in several of my patients, two of whom were helping professionals. They became attracted to these systems by other helping professionals. They were not seeking a new religion or religious experience; they said they were simply exploring methods of helping to become more effective in their professional and personal lives.

Collaborating With Clergy

For those with family, friends, or loved ones experiencing mental health issues in a crisis, the first thing is to follow this triage: if there is potential for harm to self, or others, or if there is an inability to care for themselves, call the emergency line in your area for immediate assistance.

Subsequently, if a person is suffering from symptoms related to anxiety, depression, stress, or trauma who is not in immediate danger, then the next step is to approach your clergy to see if they are aware of any Catholic professionals in the area. If there are no Catholic professionals, seek those who respect the personโ€™s belief system and who do not promote any of the New Age practices mentioned in this article.

I strongly recommend encouraging the person receiving mental health care to sit with their priest monthly, or more frequently, if possible, to describe their process of treatment and discuss any of the strategies taught by the practitioner to assess for any potential misalignment with Church teaching. This is simply a prudential measure to protect the parishioner who is likely quite vulnerable during this time.

Pax Christiโ€”and โ€œWith all vigilance guard your heart, for in it are the sources of lifeโ€ (Prov. 4:23).


Photo by Arina Krasnikova on Pexels

Donald Froyd

Donald โ€œRickโ€ Froyd, Ph.D. is a semiโ€‘retired Catholic psychotherapist and scholarโ€‘practitioner who teaches graduate counseling courses at New Mexico Highlands University. His academic work focuses on patristic anthropology, Evagrian spirituality, and the integration of ascetical theology with contemporary clinical practice. He lives in the high desert of New Mexico with his family, where he continues writing and teaching in the contemplative tradition of the Desert Fathers.

Feature Our Authors on your Show!

Want to interview one of our authors on your podcast or radio show?
Weโ€™d love to hear from you.

Contact Us

Tap into The Wellspring daily

Spiritual direction, encouragement, and edification in your inbox every weekday.

Newsletter signup

Most popular

Share to...