Our Lady of All Nations: The Fifth Dogma

Pope Francis’ entrustment of the world to Our Lady of Fatima has rekindled interest among Catholics about Marian apparitions.  The Lady of Fatima apparition came to Portugal in the last stages of bloody World War I, while another, largely ignored Marian apparition occurred in another small European country, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, in the last gasps of World War II.  While Fatima is well known for the Blessed Mother’s warnings and predictions of coming events in world politics, the apparitions in Amsterdam had even more to say about the future of the world and humanity.  And the apparitions in Amsterdam offered a new Marian dogma much as the Rue Du Bac, Paris apparitions to Saint Catherine Laboure in 1830 heralded the proclamation of the dogma of the Immaculate Conception.  The Amsterdam apparitions, moreover, offered humanity help should the Church proclaim a fifth and final Marian dogma.

Our recent article on the Fifth Marian dogma sparked a considerable amount of debate and discussion on the pages of Catholic Exchange.  Our article referenced the Lady of All Nations Marian apparitions that happened over the course of years in the wake of World War II in Amsterdam.  Bishop Jozef Marianus Punt, the Bishop of Haarlem and Amsterdam, courageously declared in 2002 that this series of Marian apparitions were of supernatural origin and were worthy of belief.

Still though, the promotion of the Lady of All Nations devotion and mission has been hampered a lack of education about the apparitions as well as by controversies, disputes, and misinformation.  Such seems to be the case with many, if not, all Marian apparitions.  They go through a terrible time of trial before they become widely accepted and venerated by the faithful, much like the histories of Lourdes and Fatima in which visionaries or seers were treated harshly by both civil and Church authorities.

We would like to aid and clarify some of these problems for the Lady of All Nations, especially because her warnings of the state of the world today are so timely and her offer of heavenly assistance is so urgently needed.  First, we would like to share with you what the Lady of All Nations was asking of humanity in the Amsterdam apparitions.  The Lady of All Nations is one of the most important Marian apparitions in the history of the Church. It is a capstone, if you will, for the long history of Marian apparitions.

What the Lady of All Nations Asked for in Amsterdam

The Amsterdam apparition consisted of fifty-six messages given from 1945 to 1959 by the Lady of All Nations to a single Dutch woman, Ida Peerdeman, who worked as a secretary in Amsterdam.  This woman was a devout Catholic as well as a modest and humble person, but otherwise unremarkable in the eyes of the world.  She was a worldly “nobody,” and she acted only as an “instrument,” as the Lady of All Nations told her several times during her visitations.  That Ida was by the standards of the worldly was insignificant was entirely in keeping with other famous Marian apparitions in which the lowest of the low of humanity are used for Heavenly purposes such as St. Bernadette of Lourdes who was an illiterate shepherd girl.

The Amsterdam messages had a wide variety of content and were given with a great deal of imagery in which the Lady of All Nations conveyed to Ida an astounding acute depiction what was to come to the world.  Keep in mind that these messages were given after the Second World War that ravaged Europe and Holland in which many people looked ahead with optimism after the defeat of Nazi Germany and Catholicism flourished on the continent.  Instead, the Lady of All Nations warned of the fading away of vibrant Catholicism in Europe, disputes and conflict within the Church, the rise of secularism, the decay of tradition families, economic hardships, natural disasters, dramatic climate change, and more armed conflict—all of which has come to be in the decades since just as the Lady of All Nations had foretold and contrary to the conventional wisdom of man.

The Lady of All Nations pointed humanity’s failure to live by Christ’s teachings as the root cause of the world’s ever increasing degeneration, disaster, and war.  She said that the world paid no heed to Christ’s sacrifice on the Cross and failed to live by the commandments and the grand commandments to love God and our neighbors.

The Lady of All Nations asked humanity for several things in order to avert even far greater degeneration, disaster, and war unless humanity changed its ways.  First, she offered a powerful prayer to call down the Holy Spirit to renew the earth and asked the faithful to pray it daily:

Lord Jesus Christ, Son of the Father, send now Your Spirit over the earth.  Let the Holy Spirit live in the hearts of all nations, that they may be preserved from degeneration, disaster and war.  May the Lady of All Nations, the Blessed Virgin Mary, be our Advocate.  Amen.

The prayer has been approved by the Bishop Punt of Haarlem-Amsterdam and the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.  The wording of the prayer was slightly changed in Rome.  The original form of the prayer given by Our Lady included the expression “who once was Mary,” but was adapted to “the Blessed Virgin Mary” at the request of the Vatican Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in an effort to avoid “any pastoral misunderstanding,” which was implemented in 2006.

Image of Our Lady of Nations/Dr. Russell

Image of Our Lady of Nations/Dr. Russell

Second, the Lady asked that her image, which she has shared with Ida and which was, in turn, painted, be promoted through the world.  She asked that her image along with her prayer be printed in all languages to call down the Holy Spirit anew.  The beautiful image has the Lady standing before the cross–wearing the loin clothe Christ wore on the cross around her wait–over the world shining graces from her hands to humanity depicted around the world by white and black sheep.

Third, the Lady asked for the construction of a church in her honor in Amsterdam.  She gave fairly detailed description for the location of the Church in what was then open land, and even showed Ida what the Church will look like.  Again, the Lady’s words contradicted the common wisdom of man today.  With Catholicism dying out in Europe and churches being closed in Holland and throughout the continent, one would think that the last thing the world and the Netherlands needs is to build a new church.  But the Lady of All Nations wants a place of pilgrimage for all peoples of the world in the heart of one of the most cosmopolitan cities of the world, a cultural cross roads of today’s globalized world.

Finally, the Lady asked for the declaration of the fifth and final Marian dogma. Recall that the Church’s four Marian dogmas are Mother of God, Ever Virgin, Immaculate Conception, and the Assumption.  She asked the faithful to petition our Holy Father to declare her “Advocate, Mediatrix, and Co-redemptrix.”

The dogma would recognize Mary as the advocate for humanity before the Holy Trinity, the mediatrix through which Heavenly graces are passed from Heaven to humanity, and the co-redeemer with her Son of humanity.  The idea of Mary as co-redeemer is probably one of the most contested aspects of the Lady of All Nations apparitions.  But it is critically important to note that “co-“ means along “with,” not as an “equal” with Christ or divinity.

Instead, the dogma of Mary as co-redemptrix would officially acknowledge the unique role that Mary played in the salvation of humanity.  She is the one who gave Christ the blood to shed at the crucifixion.  And she is the only one in the Gospels who was present for the whole of Christ’s life of earth, from the beginning to the middle, and to the end.  She suffered with the Redeemer throughout his lifelong mission of redemption, which reached its climax at Calvary.  The Lady of All Nations also made it clear that the proclamation of this fifth Marian dogma was a heavenly pre-requisite for peace: “Once the dogma, the final dogma in Marian history, has been proclaimed, the Lady of All Nations will grant peace, true peace, to the world.”

Prophecies and Predictions as Authentication

The Amsterdam apparitions’ consistency with the Gospels is one mark of their authenticity.  The apparitions also emphasized the teachings and importance of the Church’s sacraments, especially the Eucharist as the actual body and blood of Christ, not just a symbol of them.  Another mark of their authenticity is the stunning number of prophecies and predictions about the course of world politics that have come to fruition over the years.  Keep in mine a distinction between “prophecy” and “prediction.”  A prophecy is a warning of what could come unless mankind changes its behavior, while a prediction is of an event that is bound to occur.   Another feature of the prophecies and predictions given at Amsterdam is the symbolism and images in the messages that appear to obscure the meanings before events, but they become almost crystal clear after the event or events take place.

Some of the prophecies and predictions given by the Lady of All Nations about international politics were the following:

  • In March 1945, in the first of the 56 messages given at Amsterdam, the Lady of All Nations showed Ida a vision of troops returning from war and told her the date May 5th.  The Lady held up the Rosary and said “It is thanks to this.”   The Netherlands was then liberated from Nazi forces by Allied troops on 5 May.
  • Ida, the seer, in 1945 saw a vision of the biblical Jewish exodus from Egypt and the Lady of All Nations said, “But Israel will rise again.”  Jewish settlers in Palestine Israel three years later in 1948 two fought a bitter war against Arab forces to establish an independent state of Israel.
  • Ida saw in 1945 an image of “China with a red flag.”  Just four years later, the communists won the Chinese civil war and adopted a red flag as its symbol in 1949.
  • The Lady of All Nations showed Ida in 1950 an image and let her experience some of the affects of a huge explosion that scorched a plain in Russia.  The Soviet Union three years later detonated a hydrogen bomb, the power of which made the American atomic bombs dropped on Japan during World War II look like firecrackers.
  • Ida was warned in 1949 of the conflict that broke out on the Korean Peninsula.  The North Korean attack on South Korea in 1950 shocked the western world.  Ida was shown “demarcations being made at intervals.”  An armistice ended open warfare, but the border separating the two countries grew into the most heavily armed one in the world today just as Ida had seen in the Amsterdam vision.
  • The Lady of All Nations in a 1950 vision showed Germany and Europe divided into two.  She passed her hand over the dividing wall and it quietly disappeared.  The wall that divided Europe in Berlin during the Cold War collapsed decades later in 1989.  And contrary to the common wisdom that the Cold War could only go away with the clash of arms between the United States and the Soviet Union, it faded away peacefully as implied by the Lady of All Nations’ vision.
  • The Lady of All Nations showed Ida in 1947 a vision of Cairo, Egypt and she warned, “The world is, so to speak, going to be torn in two.”  Egypt had a major political convulsion in 2011 in which an authoritarian leader was ousted after decades in power.  The uprising set led to a chain reaction of political upheaval throughout the Middle East and has given windows of opportunity for militant Islamic movements to rise in power.  A Middle East emboldened with militant Islamic ideology in opposition with Western culture is certainly consistent with the Lady of All Nations’ warning decades earlier of a world “torn apart.”

One of these predictions or prophecies coming into being could be readily dismissed by a skeptical observer as a “fluke” or as a “lucky guess.”  Two of them could be disregarded as mere coincidence.  Three or more of them would have even the most jaded of observers—if he or she were open-minded and objective—wondering what is going on here?  By and large, international relations scholars do a very poor job of predicting future events and none saw all the events predicted and prophesied by the Lady of All Nations.

Dangers Lying Ahead

With such an impressive record of prediction and prophecy, we should take heed of the Lady of All Nations’ warnings for the future.

  • The Lady warned of climate change that was to occur to the planet.  The warnings came at a when no one spoke of “global warming” or the “new normal” in the face of ever increasing and disastrous storms the likes of hurricane Sandy which recently crashed into the United States’ east coast.
  • She warned of coming economic and currency crisis.  Today, when the European Union’s currency, the Euro, appears to be coming undone with the economic crises in numerous member states such as Greece, Spain, Portugal, Ireland, and Italy these warnings seem to be coming to fruition.
  • The Lady of All Nations also warned of problems inside the Catholic Church.  Certainly, the pedophilia crisis which erupted in the church in the United States and throughout the world in the past decade dovetail with the Lady’s warnings.
  • She warned in 1951 of internal conflict in China, but foretold of the subsequent rise of Catholicism in China, “After much fighting, China will return to Mother Church.  After much fighting.”
  • She showed Ida images and let her experience some of the horrible chemical and biological warfare.  Chemical warfare already been used many times in combat to include most recently in Syria, but biological warfare has not been used to the extent of which the Lady of All Nations implied in her visitation.
  • She warned in a 1955 vision, “A time of great inventions is to come.  There will be alarming inventions, such that even your shepherds will be astonished and say: ‘we are at a loss.’”  She reiterated, “I just said: alarming inventions will be made.  God allows this; but you peoples, you can see to it that it does not result in disaster. You peoples, I beg you…So that you do not arrive at alarming things, nations, the Lady begs you now, today: ask the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit to protect His people, to bring His people to unity once again.  People have to attain unity, to be one, and over them: the Lady of All Nations.”

We Should Listen and Act

Taken collectively, these predictions and prophecies of dangers looming in humanity’s cut against the grain of the common mind of western world.  The western elite collectively is infused with philosophy from the Enlightenment that mankind is on a steady march of progress and becoming ever better and humanity and has no need for God in the process.  The cosmopolitan western elite believes that technology and democracy promotion is the means for mankind’s path toward perfection.

In its arrogance, the cosmopolitan elite ignores the fact that their counterparts in rising powers from the Middle East to Asia do not share their philosophic idealism.  Instead, they are motivated by militant religious ideology, the pursuit for raw power, or some combination of the two.  The cosmopolitan western elite clings to its atheistic worldview even in the face of stubborn realities with the world degenerating, experiencing more natural- and man-made disasters and wars, just as the Lady of All Nations warned.

The Lady of All Nations’ prophecies and predictions are warnings of what is to come unless humanity changes course.  We have it in our power to avoid the calamities of which she warned.  That indeed the motherly advice given at Amsterdam; the Lady of All Nations offers all nations and peoples of the world hope by turning to her Son and the life according to the Gospels.  She warned in 1950, “You will see that only after much misery and many disasters will the Cross again be raised up.  Everyone shall do one’s part, according to one’s ability.  And I again point out the first and greatest commandment: Love, Love of Neighbor.”

The Lady gave us the weapons need to avert degeneration, disaster, and war.  But we have to do our part.  We have to ask for Heavenly help.  We should say daily the prayer the Lady of All Nations gave us, spread her image in all languages around the world, and help establish a Lady of All Nations church in Amsterdam.

All the while, we are charged by the Lady of All Nations to petition the Holy Father for his declaration of the Fifth and Final Marian dogma, Mary as Advocate, Mediatrix, and Co-Redemptrix.  The Lady of All Nations said clearly and directly to Ida, “Child, pass it on well that those who fight and work for this cause, which the Son wants to be realized, are to do so with great ardor and zeal.”  She offered no caveats or qualifications such as when it is convenient, politically expedient, or easy—she simply said “with great ardor and zeal.”  Our task is to petition or encourage, support, protect, follow, and love the Holy Father, not to try to impose anything on Christ’s vicar on earth.  With the extremely Marian Pope Francis, the “Pope of the People” at the Church’s helm, we have every reason to write to him in confidence that our petitions will be heard and discerned.

For further relections on the Virgin Mary, see Professor Miravalle’s Meet Mary, available from Sophia Institute Press

image: Shutterstock

Dr. Mark Miravalle and Richard L Russell

By

Dr. Mark Miravalle is Professor of Theology and Mariology at Franciscan University of Steubenville. He is the author of Meet Mary: Getting To Know The Mother of God among numerous other books pertaining to Mariology. Along with his international travels, he has appeared on radio, television, and a number of conferences. Richard L. Russell, a Catholic convert, holds a Ph.D. in Foreign Affairs from the University of Virginia and specializes in foreign policy and international security. He is the author of three books: Sharpening Strategic Intelligence (Cambridge University Press); Weapons Proliferation and War in the Greater Middle East (Routledge); and, George F. Kennan’s Strategic Thought (Praeger).

Subscribe to CE
(It's free)

Go to Catholic Exchange homepage

  • JMC

    I have never heard of this apparition before, but from what you have written here, it is clear to me that it is an indisputable extension of the message of Fatima. In fact, some of the predictions and prophecies Our Lady gave to Miss Peerdeman jibe perfectly with what we know of the contents of the Third Secret, as hinted at by people who have read it, but, due to oaths of confidentiality, could not clearly reveal the specifics of what it contains. Pope Benedict himself proclaimed the conflicts within the Church as part of the Secret, after his visit to Fatima where he proclaimed, “He decieves himself who says Fatima belongs to the past.”
    I did not participate in the discussion about the Fifth Marian Dogma simply because I did not know enough about it. With the information you give here, it becomes clear to me that this declaration is right up there with the Consecration of Russia and the revelation of the COMPLETE Third Secret. I will be adding the prayer given here to my daily Marian devotions.
    Thank you so much for this article!

  • BillinJax

    Le

    Excuse Me!
    She asked the faithful to petition our Holy Father to
    declare her “Advocate, Mediatrix, and Co-redemptrix.”

    And then you say, “The idea of Mary as co-redeemer is
    probably one of the most contested aspects of the Lady of All Nations
    apparitions.”

    How in the world could we as Catholics even hesitate to question ourselves in this regard? Maybe those of us who take the time to think about it are unaware we are heretics but it’s almost silly to believe we have to have a discussion on such an issue as wondering if we could go so far as to refer to Our Blessed Mother as “Advocate, Mediatrix, and Co-redemptrix” when for years we and all Roman Catholics have for been referring to her as “The Mother of God”.

    Literally, we would have to say for heaven’s sake what other
    criteria or justification should there be? What greater accolade do we need?
    Let’s stop pretending we don’t know where to place scriptures “woman” for all
    ages and time within the framework of salvation. The Father pointed to her immediately after the fall and Christ acknowledged her from his cross as the woman humanity required to fulfill his promise.

    Why debate the obvious?

  • Raquel Lopez

    Yes, indeed it is time! More than ever, this world needs heaven’s help to be preserved from “degeneration, disaster and war”. I personally have petitioned the Holy Father to declare Mary as Co-Redemptrix, Mediatrix, and Advocate of humanity in the fifth dogma. Please, prayerfully consider doing the same. Mail letter to Pope Francis, Vatican City, 00120

  • Myshkin

    There is no need of a fifth Marian dogma. The proclamation of a dogma, by definition, is something that must be believed in order to claim oneself to be one with the Church in belief. There is nothing but trouble waiting by going down the path of proclaiming that in order to be Catholic — and, presumably, fully Christian, and in communion with the Catholic Church — one MUST believe in Mary as “co-redemptrix.”

    The proponents of this fifth “dogma” do so at great risk.

    If I do not believe that Mary is “co-redemptrix” with Christ, even in the sense of “along with,” then you are ready to declare me a heretic and at grave risk of losing my immortal soul.

    I think that the title “co-redemptrix” is a title “too far.”

    All you other bloggers, tell me: Exactly what do you propose that we believe about Mary that is not already taught by Holy Mother Church, and why is such belief necessary to salvation? Isn’t that what you are proposing? That as a dogma, belief in the “co-redemptrix” is necessary for salvation?

    Why? Why is this needed?

    I just can’t see it at all. It is NOT necessary for salvation to append this title to Mary. Totally unnecessary.

  • Myshkin

    There is no need of a fifth Marian dogma. The proclamation of a dogma, by definition, is something that must be believed in order to claim oneself to be one with the Church in belief. There is nothing but trouble waiting by going down the path of proclaiming that in order to be Catholic — and, presumably, fully Christian, and in communion with the Catholic Church — one MUST believe in Mary as “co-redemptrix.”

    The proponents of this fifth “dogma” do so at great risk.

    If I do not believe that Mary is “co-redemptrix” with Christ, even in the sense of “along with,” then you are ready to declare me a heretic and at grave risk of losing my immortal soul.

    I think that the title “co-redemptrix” is a title “too far.”

    All you other bloggers, tell me: Exactly what do you propose that we believe about Mary that is not already taught by Holy Mother Church, and why is such belief necessary to salvation? Isn’t that what you are proposing? That as a dogma, belief in the “co-redemptrix” is necessary for salvation?

    Why? Why is this needed?

    I just can’t see it at all. It is NOT necessary for salvation to append this title to Mary. Totally unnecessary.

  • Harry Flynn

    I would still like to see Dr. Miravalle address the question of Punt’s jurisdiction on this matter in light of the Holy See’s 1974 Notification on the subject.

  • fishman

    My disclaimer is I’m a fence sitter on this issue:

    I’d also like to add a disclaimer that I’m not entirely certain what the phrase ‘knowledge NESSARY to salvation’ means. As it would seem, given God’s mercy and grace that the only knowledge truly NESSARY for salvation is that which he has granted you and you willing accept. Otherwise what can be made of the issue idea that there is ‘good reason to hope’ that the un-baptized may be in heaven. So from here on I use necessary in the context of ( in the coarse of normal Christian development as revealed by Christ). As oppose to what ever extraordinary acts of mercy God may perform for those who through no fault of their own remain ignorant of necessary knowledge.

    What is it that is necessary for salvation in the dogma of Mary as co-redepmtrist and mediatirix of all Graces.

    1) That the catholic church is necessary to salvation. Mary is consider a in much of scripture an image of the church or vice versa. To declare Mary as mediatirx is to insist that you cannot reach haven without passing through ‘mother church’ either in this life or joining her in the next, but it is not possible without her. ( and under normal circumstances that truth is necessary for salvation).

    2) It is necessary and right that human beings ‘take up their cross and follow Christ’ and in doing so we actively participate in his action of saving souls.
    If Mary a human being is able to co-redeem the world with Christ then it follows so can anyone else. Christ said ‘who is my mother and my brothers, those that do the will of my father in heaven’. So each of us has the ability to become ‘the mother of Jesus’ in a mystical fashion. In doing so each of us has the ability , perhaps even the moral obligation to participate in the suffering of Christ for the purpose of the redemption of the world. (this explains the need for fasting , almsgiving ect. ).

    I would hold that those two truth are
    a) already believed.
    b) necessary for salvation
    c) would be clarified by a properly understood declaration of mary as co-redemptrist and mediatrix of all grace.

    Is it the right time to make such a declaration, or would it merely cause schism and upset? Is it better to challenge the people of God to deepen their love and understanding of Christ OR to keep the message of the day less like solid food and more like a mothers milk. (for the sake of those who are spiritually immature).

    I don’t know. That is a question of debate, but not one the laity can answer. It really MUST be left to those who have the vocation (calling) and charism (guidance) of the holy sprit to answer.

  • Lee

    Sister Lucia lived to be 87 years old, dieing in 2005; and never once turned against Mary, who appeared at Fatima. We wait for miracles and when we are not witness we deny their possibility. I think we all are asked to believe and to act. When it comes to our Mother Mary, mother of God, we should respond in prayer. Why wait to see what happens next. Our Pope, Frances will do God’s Will, so we do not have to feel like we are making a mistake. I never feel I’m being duped when we call upon the Holy Spirit.

  • pbecke

    Sometimes more is less. Previous dogmatic pronouncements have confirmed information of a recondite nature, long believed by the faithful. However, it seems to me, that Our Lady’s roles in both Our Lord’s Incarnation and in his Passion speaks for themselves, so, personally, I can’t help thinking that it would be redundant. It is, indeed, also, needlessly ambiguous and, would, therefore, understandably, in my view, represent an obstacle to the unity of the Church.

    Already we have people imputing to Mary membership of a Holy Quadernity, in place of the Holy Trinity. Moreover, I have sometimes heard it said that when the priest celebrating the Mass, raises the Sacred Host, he becomes Christ, in his own person – which is an impossibility. We can, all of us, only ever be ‘other Christs’ by adoption – which seems honour enough, and some, to me.

    Would not Our Lady, I find myself asking, wish for a little clear water to be left between her Son’s uniquely divine, original sacrifice and her own sacrifices, which would have been as transcendant as her optimally- sublime nature as a finite creature would have allowed.

    I say all of this, while deferring to no-one in my love and veneration of Our Lady and our heavenly mother.

  • Thomas

    You are right, this is going too far. Jesus Christ is supposed to return and bring peace to the earth. It’s all about JESUS and not Mary. Granted she is his mother, she is not a Goddess or divine. Wake up Catholics. I am a Catholic, I don’t believe any of this. Jesus is my savior, he suffered and died and rose for us. God created Mary and it was through the Holy Spirit and God’s will that she bore Jesus. The blood Jesus got from Mary was from God. God created Mary. She is the earthly mother of our Lord and was blessed to be choosen to be his mother.

  • Thomas

    Jesus Christ will appear in the sky and every kneel shall bow when he comes again. That is what the bible says. Jesus never said anything about any of this stuff or said it was required. The real Mary mother of our Lord Jesus would not glorify herself and demand that churches and paintings be made of her and prayers made to her to distributed throughout the world. This is not Mary the Biblical Humble mother of Jesus. Only Jesus will grant us peace, not this non biblical Mary.

    This is a lie and borders on blasphemy:
    The Lady of All Nations also made it clear that the proclamation of this
    fifth Marian dogma was a heavenly pre-requisite for peace: “Once the
    dogma, the final dogma in Marian history, has been proclaimed, the Lady
    of All Nations will grant peace, true peace, to the world.”

MENU