Why Prophets Get Stoned

January 29th, 2007 by Marcellino D'Ambrosio, Ph.D. Print This Article Print This Article ·

"In polite conversation, never bring up politics or religion."  That's the advice I was given as a child.  And it's good advice, too, if your main goal is to make sure everybody likes you.  Politics and religion are risky because they involve deeply held convictions, and if you happen to challenge these convictions, you get the same reaction that a dentist gets when his probe hits a nerve.

But politeness at any cost is not God's style.  The reason for this is that God is love, and love is more concerned about the welfare of others than with one's own image.  So if someone is on a seemingly pleasant canoe ride down a lazy river, love cares enough to warn the passengers that Niagra Falls is up ahead.  "But everyone is entitled to his or her own opinion!"  Nevertheless, opinions don't change the fact that going over the falls in a canoe will kill you.

Religious and moral choices are like this.  They set one on a course that leads either to a safe harbor or over the falls.  Sex outside of marriage, intoxication with drugs and alcohol, honoring Jesus but rejecting the authority of His Church, all these choices have very unpleasant, even deadly, consequences.

So God sends prophets (the Greek word means "spokesmen") whose role includes warning people that they are headed over the falls.  You'd think people would be grateful for the heads up.  But often people respond to bad news by killing the messenger.

Why is this?  Because of the idea that we are basically "good people" whom God ought to appreciate, and that our beliefs and lifestyle are at least as good as all others — these are comforting illusions.  When a prophet calls all this into question, we find it threatening and very uncomfortable.  If the prophet is right, we have to change, and change always means pain, and we don't like pain.

 Jeremiah and Jesus both are dealing with people who think that they are "good people."  After all, they are God's chosen people.  They offer sacrifices.  God is on their side.   So they respond to Jeremiah's warnings by eliminating the source of pain.  They throw him into a muddy cistern and he narrowly escapes with his life.  In Luke 4, the inhabitants of Nazareth want to throw Jesus over the hill.  He eludes them this time, but ultimately gives His life for those who cry out "Crucify Him!"

So if this is how people are going to respond, why bother?  Why stick your neck out?  Because people have a right to the truth, whether they end up heeding the truth or not.  The prophet's responsibility is to speak God's word as clearly and convincingly as possible.  What people do with that word is not under his control.  Mother Teresa was fond of saying that God does not require us to have success; He requires us to be faithful.

At first glance, Jeremiah did not have much "success."  His listeners totally ignored him, the Babylonians destroyed Jerusalem, and Israel was taken into exile.  On Good Friday, it did not look like Jesus had been successful, either.  But 300 years later the Romans who crucified Him were worshiping Him, and the lives that had been forever changed were too numerous to count.

We who have been confirmed have been given a share in Christ's prophetic anointing.  If our goal is to be everybody's buddy, we are going to have a hard time being faithful.  The word that God commands us to share is sometimes comforting, sometimes disturbing.  We must get over our fear of offending people and love them enough to tell them the truth.  Of course, there is always the question of the right place and time.  But if no place is the right place and the right time never comes, we can be sure that we are allowing fear of others' opinions to get in the way of love.  Love is not about being sentimental or popular.  The love of God, spoken about in 1 Corinthians 13, is tough love.

Dr. D'Ambrosio studied under Avery Cardinal Dulles for his Ph.D. in historical theology and taught for many years at the University of Dallas. He now directs www.crossroadsinitiative.com, which offers Catholic resources for RCIA and adult and teen faith formation, with a special emphasis on the Eucharist, the Theology of the Body, the early Church Fathers, and the Sacrament of Confirmation.

(This article originally appeared in Our Sunday Visitor and is used by permission of the author.)




5 Comments For This Post

  1. Guest says:

    So true! But the prophetic voice is virtually absent from the Catholic Church! And we should be the loudest voice of all just because the Church is Truth. Why is this? Teaching philosophy to undergrads, I am perennially appalled by most students's a priori rejection of truth. Also as one who has thoroughly studided the philosophical roots of the rejection of truth from the Sophists, Enlightenment, Nietzsche, Derrida, and current postmodernists I am familiar with the arguments and particularly the deficiencies of the arguments. The modern currents of relativism and postmodernism are products of such thinking that has crept not only into the hearts and minds of students, but also into that of Catholic Christians, lay and priest alike. The prophetic voice is an urgent voice that calls back to absolute truth. Thus, no firm convincing argument and defense of the Absolute Truth of Christ and Church among believers as absolute and universal, then no prophetic voice proclaiming Truth amidst this stormy sea of "many truths, my truth and your truth, all is good, tolerance at all costs, my Jesus and your Jesus, etc."  Conclusion: the world urgently needs the prophetic voice but that voice will not emerge until those in the Chuech, especially the priests, become convinced of Christ and Church as Absolute.  

  2. Guest says:

    lwall — your comments are so true but I respectfully disagree with you on one point; the head of our Church (John Paul II and Benedict XVI) has not been silent but has spoken out numerous times on the evils that attack our faith.  I will agree with you wholeheartedly that the message needs to be reinforced frequently among our bishops and priests.  Thanks for the article Dr. D'Ambrosio – this is a message we all need to hear.  May God continue to bless you and your work!    

  3. Guest says:

    I would like to thank you for your insight.  I teach science and health at a Catholic High School.  (I am a certified teacher as well as an RN with 30 years experience in maternal-child health.) It has been an uphill battle to teach the politically incorrect, yet factually correct truths about the "safe sex" delusion.  Your comment about loving the students enough to tell them the truth and society's tendency to shoot the messenger of an unpopular message has been part of my presentation for several years now.  I would like to share with all of you how positively the message of abstinence has been received by the students.  Overwhelmingly, in the course evaluations, the students thank me for telling them the truth - and for giving them the tools needed to do what's right - and HEALTHY. The "battle" I mentioned earlier is with the other teachers - not the students.

  4. Guest says:

    Therese,

    thanks for your beautiful witness to the truth, and the great reminder that we lay people are also called to be God's spokesmen as well.  We need to rejoice when we are persecuted, for this is exactly what Christ said would happen.

  5. Guest says:

    As my Mormon buddy said " were here to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable"

    Rolland

     

Leave a Reply

Comments May Not Display Immediately

You must be logged in to post a comment.

CE Spotlight

Faith Factory

Champions of Faith Ad