Iโve been involved in the technology world for more than thirty years, and Iโve never seen anything like this. Iโm referring to the intense anti-AI sentiment that exists in the United States (and much of the Western world). Although my lifetime has seen the introduction of a number of culture-altering technologies, none has faced the backlash that AI is currently experiencing.
Why is that?
Well, for one, AI is weird. Previous technologies, such as the internet and the smartphone, still presented themselves as tools, as machines. Our brains know how to deal with that. AI, however, is designed to seem like something it isnโt: human. Iโve told computers to do things for decades, but until recently, I told them either by writing computer code or by following a series of steps laid out for me (move mouse here, click, etc.). Now I can just interact with a computer like I interact with a co-worker: in human language, even with its imprecisions and mistakes. And like a human (often more efficiently than a human), it will do what I tell it to do. Letโs be honest: thatโs unsettling. Itโs weird. So thereโs a natural hesitation toward embracing this new, strange technology.
But thereโs also fear involved in our hesitation. After all, rarely does a day go by in which we donโt see a headline declaring that most of us will be out of work soon, due to AI. Or even worse, we see an AI leader matter-of-factly stating that the technology that he himself is building may end up destroying humanity (often followed by, โBut you need to invest in my company!โ). Itโs not unreasonable to be fearful in such an environment.
However, Iโm here to tell you that Catholics need not fear the coming of AI. Properly understoodโand properly usedโit can be a tool used for the common good and for human flourishing. This is the Catholic attitude toward new technologies: embrace how they better our world, while warning of the dangers of their misuse. Many Catholics donโt realize that the Church has been giving guidance on new technologies for decades, and that guidance consistently follows this pattern.
For example, in his 1957 encyclical Miranda Prorsus, Pope Pius XII wrote regarding the then relatively new technologies of motion pictures, radio, and television, calling them โgifts of God.โ
Those very remarkable technical inventions which are the boast of the men of our generation, though they spring from human intelligence and industry, are nevertheless the gifts of God, Our Creator, from Whom all good gifts proceed: โfor He has not only brought forth creatures, but sustains and fosters them once created.โ (Miranda Prorsus)
But he also warned about their dangers:
For these new possessions and new instruments which are within almost everyoneโs grasp, introduce a most powerful influence into menโs minds, both because they can flood them with light, raise them to nobility, adorn them with beauty, and because they can disfigure them by dimming their lustre, dishonour them by a process of corruption, and make them subject to uncontrolled passions, according as the subjects presented to the senses in these shows are praiseworthy or reprehensible. (Miranda Prorsus)
This became the pattern for Pope Pius XIIโs successors, including Pope John Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI, and Pope Leo XIV: gratitude for new technologies created by the gift of human reason, along with wariness of ways they can be abused. As Pope Leo XIV wrote regarding AI itself: it โcan be a valuable tool and, at the same time…calls for a measured and vigilant approachโ (Magnifica Humanitas, par. 100).
Thatโs no surprise, since Catholics have long been at the forefront of creating new technologies. The radioโthe first electronic mass communications deviceโwas invented by Italian Catholic Guglielmo Marconi (he even built Vatican Radio for Pope Pius XI in 1931). The concept of hypertext was pioneered by Jesuit Fr. Roberto Busa through his Index Thomisticus project. Begun in 1949, it was a digital and searchable concordance of St. Thomas Aquinasโs works. The barometer (Evangelista Torricelli), an early mechanical calculator (Blaise Pascal), the induction coil (Fr. Nicholas Callan), and the pantelegraph (Fr. Giovanni Caselli)โwhich was an early type of fax machineโwere all invented by Catholics. The Church has never been anti-technology.
Iโve seen many Catholics today take a different line with AI, however: outright rejection, often fueled by fear. The problem is that most people only interact with a small segment of what falls under the umbrella of โartificial intelligence.โ They see cringey AI slop online, or hear about job layoffs, while their only direct interaction with AI (at least that they know of) is using a chatbot as a replacement for Google. No wonder many conclude it isnโt worth the risk of a machine apocalypse.
Yet this is but a small segment of what AI can do. I know of Catholic apostolates that have been able to supercharge their work due to AI, by letting AI do many of the tedious tasks involved in running any organization while they focus on their primary mission. AI has markedly improved diagnostic accuracy and accelerated the early stages of discovering treatments for disease. AlphaFold cracked the fifty-year-old problem of predicting a proteinโs structure, a work that won the 2024 Nobel Prize in Chemistry and has revealed more of the ordered complexity of creation. Self-driving cars promise to radically reduce accidents, saving an untold number of innocent lives. As Catholics, we should embrace these advancements.
Of course, we shouldnโt ignore the dangers of AI, just as Pope Pius XII didnโt ignore the dangers of movies, television, and radio. The Church must step in to help those whose work is displaced by AI. Sensible guardrails should be put in place to prevent AI acting outside human-imposed boundaries. Most importantly, where AI is differentโand most dangerousโcompared to previous technologies is how it apes humanity: it sounds human and often acts human, yet we know it isnโt human. Pope Leo XIV makes it clear that AI is not even โalmostโ human:
So-called artificial intelligences do not undergo experiences, do not possess a body, do not feel joy or pain, do not mature through relationships and do not know from within what love, work, friendship or responsibility mean. Nor do they have a moral conscience, since they do not judge good and evil, grasp the ultimate meaning of situations, or bear responsibility for consequences. They may imitate language, behavior and analytical skills, or even simulate empathy and understanding, but they do not understand what they produce, for they lack the affective, relational and spiritual perspective through which human beings grow in wisdom. (Magnifica Humanitas, par. 99)
This is the arena Catholics are called to enter today: to challenge the assumptions made by many AI proponents, assumptions that reduce man to a machine by pretending a machine can be a man. If we just retreat into an anti-AI world, we concede this ground to the materialistic AI boosters. Instead, we must embrace the good of AIโas previous generations of Catholics embraced the good of their technological advancesโwhile preserving the distinction between man and machine.
Editor’s Note: Eric Sammons is the author of The Catholic Guide to Artificial Intelligence: Preserving the Distinction Between Man and Machine (Sophia Institute Press).
Photo by Louis Reed on Unsplash
