About a year ago, I made a no-AI commitment while writing my childrenโs book, Created, Not Coded. I stand by that commitment because formation should never be trusted to algorithms. However, my reading of Magnifica Humanitas gave me a conviction that Catholics have to be at the table and participating in AI in order to build in the โconstruction site of our time.โ The construction site of our time was Pope Leo XIVโs nod to Nehemiah rebuilding the wall of Jerusalem with the assistance of everyone in the community. Iโve slowly started discerning ways to integrate AI into workflows, even though itโs uncomfortable and takes time.
In the debate around Catholics using AI, there are two comfortable positions on either side of the spectrum: (1) accelerate and create the most possible Catholic applications of generative AI and (2) wholesale dismissal, forgoing all generative AI. I sit in the middle, this gray area between acknowledging that sometimes GenAI can be a helpful tool and other times itโs dangerously close to replacing the real things that make me human. In either extreme, thereโs a script, an obvious community, and clear marching orders. Here in the middle, on a path of continual discernment, there is no script. Iโm figuring out this middle lane because all or nothing didnโt work for me.
Discernment feels tricky because weโre trained to expect instant responses, connections, and likes. Weโre no longer comfortable wrestling with questions and waiting for answers. Pope Leo recognized this, saying that the digital environment โfosters a culture of immediacy and hyper-stimulation, which gives rise to fatigue, boredom, and apathyโ (Magnifica Humanitas, par. 139). The time it takes to form our thoughts about AI is particularly tricky because the technology is advancing rapidly, often changing the ways we could use it and where we might encounter it.
Prudence is a virtue precisely because the right action isnโt always obvious. Prudence isnโt cautiously avoiding, but the virtue that precedes action. The Catechism of the Catholic Church defines prudence as โthe virtue that disposes practical reason to discern our true good in every circumstance and to choose the right means of achieving itโ (CCC 1806). Through prudence, we decide how to move from discernment to action. A prudent person must take action with the knowledge they have garnered. St. Thomas Aquinas says that prudence is โright reason in actionโ (CCC 1806).
How is prudence applied to artificial intelligence and discernment? In Magnifica Humanitas, Pope Leo wrote, โEducating people about the use of AI, then, involves teaching them to decide when and for what purpose it ought not to be usedโ (par. 140). The decision we have to make is not about walking away altogether, but how to use the tools properly. Notice what Pope Leo XIV does not say: he doesnโt say, โdonโt use AI tools.โ A โnoโ that comes from reflexive fear is much different than a โnoโ reached by thorough discernment, even though the outcome is identical.
Pope Leo chose Nehemiah as our guide through these conversations about artificial intelligence because he already used the framework we need:
Nehemiah heard the cry of a devastated city, brought that pain to prayer, discerned before God, asked for help, received permission to return, organized the work, confronted internal and external resistance and rebuilt the walls of Jerusalem with the assistance of the people, brick by brick. (Magnifica Humanitas, par. 241)
Discernment sits in the middle of this list, after the prayer and before the work. He faced resistance, he faced challenges, but with faith and a solid discernment, he knew he could proceed with confidence.
Pope Leo also says we have to enter this construction site, or this โera of digital transformationโ (Magnifica Humanitas, par. 241). He calls us to โassume an active role, without taking refuge in spiritual sentimentality or retreating into our own little worldsโ (par. 236). It is here, in the middle of all the AI building, that Catholics have to figure out what weโre going to build and how. There is a place along the whole spectrum of AI adoption, but the discernment has to be made individually for each of us.
Here are three things to consider as you discern AI yourself:
Am I Comfortable in the Quiet?
Discernment is tricky when there is nowhere for quiet. We live in an action-packed, information-overload world today. Being able to sit in quiet contemplation is a key aspect to being able to discern appropriately. It also gives us a chance to exist in the discomfort of uncertainty.
What Is This AI Tool Replacing?
The question is not whether the tool is good or bad, but how itโs shaping or replacing ourselves. Recently, we used an LLM to better understand a blight violation given to our home about trash can storage because we couldnโt find the actual city code on our own. It gave us a chance to find the information and talk about it together. It didnโt replace a relationship or growth opportunity. It would be a very different thing, though, if I used AI to write this article and try to communicate truths of the Faith to you.
Am I Using This AI Tool Because I Decided To, or Because It Was There?
Intentionality is part of discernment. If we just constantly use an AI tool because itโs just the easiest thing to do, weโre not participating in the discernment process. It will become increasingly easy to use AI on autopilot because it is becoming more ubiquitous. However, taking that extra time to truly discern can help ensure our AI usage is oriented toward good outcomes, not just convenience.
While Magnifica Humanitas gives us a framework to follow and calls Catholics to a deeper discernment in use of tools, it doesnโt give clear rules. Thereโs a wisdom in that because every Catholic will have different answers to the discernment process, finding different ways that using AI magnifies their gifts or tempts them to replace irreplaceable human connections. We can all learn from Nehemiah by looking for ways to pray, discern, and then build.
Photo by Solen Feyissa on Pexels
