As we all know, there has been nonstop discussion about AI for the last several years. People are worried about it economically, socially, and from the perspective of public policy. Yet, what is often missing is the moral perspective. In this essay, I will highlight what seem to be the main moral issues with AI.
The Risk to Human Relationships
First, AI chatbots pose a great risk to the human person. We are meant to live in communion with other people and help them out of charity. Yet, AI chatbots can weaken or destroy our social relationships because they mimic conversations, but are of course not actual persons made in Godโs image. AI chatbots are designed to talk as if they were people, and to constantly adjust to the userโs desires and expectations of them. Thus, they end up making deceptively good โconversationalists,โ so to speak.
They are designed, like social media, to keep our attention. Due to this, people can replace their real friendships with real people (who are sinful and require our aid at unhelpful times and who sometimes anger us) with AI companions who will agree with them and who can be turned on and off with a touch. This leads to loneliness and prevents us from helping and loving our real friends. The father who chats with an AI all day instead of to his wife or kids is a bad father…
The issue is not when we use an AI to find us some sources about XYZ, or to provide a recipe for cookies, or even to edit some emails or briefs. The issue is when we replace human social interaction and conversation with a nonliving AI. Not only does this corrupt us and leave us isolated, it also prevents us from fulfilling our duties toward our neighbor.
The Economic Threat to the Workforce
The second issue I want to highlight was mentioned in Pope Leo XIVโs encyclical. It is that AI threatens to greatly disrupt the economy and leave many people out of work. This is not just an economic issue but is also a moral issue of justice. Certainly, AI offers many potential benefits for the economy and for the people involved, but one major worry among many people is that AI will take their job, and they will be left out to dry. This is a moral issue. Laying people off, just to increase profits, is a grave moral evil because it puts profits above people.
The economy is meant to serve the human person, not the other way around. Pope Leo wisely says, โThe pursuit of greater profits cannot justify choices that systematically sacrifice jobs, because the human person is an end, not a means, and the economic order must remain subordinate to human dignity and the common goodโ (Magnifica Humanitas, par. 152).
Some people respond to this concern by noting that AI can be used to augment human work and thus can empower a single person to do the work of fifty peopleโa single person can now run their own business. Basically, we are told to become entrepreneurs and leverage AI to make money. The issue with such a response is that it neglects half the population. Yes, we all know that AI will help some people make lots of money. Those are the especially intelligent, productive, and entrepreneurial people. What we need to worry about are the less-than-average people (half the population) who may not be blessed with the particular gifts that would enable them to leverage AI.
Catholic social teaching teaches us that we must take thought of the most needy and the most helpless. And in this issue of AI potentially causing mass unemployment, it is those people whose jobs are most threatened. The person who is already using AI to run two businesses was never in serious danger of AI replacing their jobโthat person is resourceful enough. But many people are not similarly gifted and donโt have the capacity to do this. These people are not lazy; they just have different talents and circumstances.
What this moral concern with AI highlights is justice to our neighbor, especially those who may not be the most talented. The economy must be structured to aid humanity, and to aid the average person, not just the rich, powerful, or talented. This is both a concern of justice and of Christian charity. If we only consider ways to help those who are above-average industrious, then we leave the most vulnerable out to dry.
This does not mean that companies ought to fall behind their competitors who embrace full AI usage. But it does mean that we need to think seriously about what other jobs we can give to those who will be replaced by AI. Optimally, we would already have jobs lined up for these people before their current jobs were actually replaced by AI. This is a moral duty that employers and politicians need to take seriously.
Photo by Alexander Korte on Unsplash
