In 2016, Yale University students asked their professors to stop assigning readings from English poets, as there is a preponderance of White male poets, and the White voice has been dominant for too long.
For many years I taught at a college where the White voice was not dominant, indeed where there was incredible diversity in a variety of racial and ethnic backgrounds. Yet I still assigned the Great Books. In one class in particular, an Honors First Year Seminar class, I required students to select a Great Book of their own choosing, write a paper, and give a talk.
Will a student select a White male such as Shakespeare, Chaucer, Homer, Gibbon, or Rousseau? I had no parameters. This assignment was color and gender blind. Students could pick any Great Book, by a woman or manโBlack, White, Hispanic, Asian, Jewish. My only requirement was that the book be considered by the intellectual community at large, by librarians and scholars and teachers, as a profound work of literature. Why assign such a book?
Reading a Great Book can engender in students the ability to examine a text, ask questions, seek answers, come up with a creative interpretation of what they have read, and write intelligent, critical essays, and make intelligent, critical comments, based on their reading and thinking.
In recent years, in many educational and literary settings, and among writers in print and online forums, there is a call for students to eschew the world of higher education, to eschew the Great Books, and to find their way in trade or technical schools.
To be sure, some students are not cut out for higher education. I have seen hundreds of such students in the scores of classes I have taught for over forty years as a college professor, and yet it concerns me when I hear blanket statements such as (from a recent article):
We send students through classes in high school until eighteen and then make them take those same classes again for the first two years of college. We keep people trapped in a system where all they want to do is move on to the subject areas they plan to devote their lives to.
The reason why students often have to retake courses in their first two years of college is because high school has not prepared them for the rigors of writing, analysis, interpretation, and thought that college requires. Yes, some students feel stuck, but there is a reason why education theory and practice for the past two thousand and more years has been focused on the Great Books. These books form the foundations for the Liberal Arts.
Over the many years I have taught, I have sought to create the conditions under which students can achieve an excellent liberal arts education, stimulating questioning, seeking, discovery, analysis, and rhetoric, which have always been the core of the Liberal Arts, which focuses on human expression and human experience over time in history, philosophy, religion, science, society, culture, government, and institutions.
The Great Books stimulate the traditional philosophy of the Liberal Arts, which was based in the Trivium (grammar, logic, and rhetoric) and the Quadrivium (arithmetic, geometry, music, and astronomy). These seven objects of inquiry and their modern equivalents form an important foundation for an educated person who pursues lifelong learning, provides an important basis for personal philosophy, and provides tools for success in a variety of careers. Liberal Arts involve the study of those subjects that open the mind and help bring about a free people.
The seven objects of inquiryโgrammar (literature, languages), logic (philosophy, deductive and inductive thinking, theology), rhetoric (history, humanities), arithmetic (numerical reasoning and inductive thinking), geometry (spatial reasoning and deductive thinking), music (arts, studies in culture and human expression), and astronomy (the hard sciences)โform the essence of the liberal arts: to question, to seek, to learn, to know, and to accept others and oneself.
The Trivium and Quadrivium engage their adherents, young and old, in spiritual seeking, emotional and natural thinking, focusing on the intellect and past tradition, finding solutions to the manifold problems of life: in short, self-discovery.
The Great Books, an essential component of the Liberal Arts curriculum, help students to acquire knowledge about the nature of humanity, helping a person to become more reflective about the self, which helps in developing sophisticated forms of thought, such as conceptualizing human experience based on analysis rather than guesswork. Knowing more about humanity over time, students break from human credulity to have a more critical assessment of lifeโs experiences.
Increasingly in the 21st century, human organizations and institutionsโcorporate, educational, and governmentalโseek thoughtful, reflective employees who can conceptualize phenomena, understand patterns, analyze problems, form hypotheses, and suggest and implement solutions. These employees, educated people who are engaged in lifelong learning, are literate and articulate communicators.
And what are the Great Books? Too numerous to list, too wonderful to sum up in a few words. But think: over the past two thousand years, many of the Great Books, until only recently, were authored by Catholic men and women who relied on their religious education, contemplation, and writing to provide beautiful, wonderful assessments of life, nature, humanity, human culture, religion, God, and the Church.
Aurelius Augustine was a student of the Greco-Roman classics. Initially, he was inspired by such writers as Cicero and Seneca to renounce Christianity. But the foundations in his learning bore fruit over the years, and he came to a point where he converted, the experience of which he recounted in his Confessions, one of the greatest books ever written. His education had not been easy in schools with severe, brutal schoolmasters. But the learning formed the basis of his thinking, his questioning, his searching for truth. We have the brilliant City of God to thank for his early schooling.
The Great Book by Michel de Montaigne, Essays, is great because of Montaigneโs utter humility, his belief that education should fit the child, that not everyone should be a great scholar, but that it is books that provide us with the knowledge to know what we know and donโt know, what we wish to do and not do, what are the questions that perplex us and what are the means to find answers. He was as skeptical toward education as many people are today, but his skepticism was tempered by his library, in which he surrounded himself with his friends, with Plutarch, Seneca, Horace, Livy, and so many of the great classical authors. The knowledge they gave him allowed Montaigne the pleasure and the right to be skeptical toward others and their pretenses to know. The Great Books formed him.
I cut my teeth as a high school senior and college freshman and sophomore on the Great Books, especially the ancient Greek, Roman, Hebrew, and Christian classics from the first millennium B.C. and first millennium A.D. I seek to inspire students likewise to begin their pursuit of knowledge by means of a thoughtful examination of the great words of a great mind between the covers of a Great Book.
Image from Wikimedia Commons
