Lesson in Love from St. Teresa Benedicta of the Cross

These last weeks have revealed, with increasing ardor, a horror in our nation. The undercover videos showing top Planned Parenthood doctors discussing the sale of aborted baby parts for experimentation and profit have utterly made my heart break.  It is so easy to feel despair, hopelessness, numbness, and incredible sadness when we see it, and even more so when we see the response of so many of our friends who defend the practice.  Even the president of the organization, Cecile Richards, defended this practice saying that it is “life-saving research,” and “important and compassionate.” Such a tragedy, ending lives needlessly in a vain attempt to save others.  If such an ethic seems mind-boggling to you, that is because it is.  Such an ethic simply does not work because it is premised upon the killing of others.  Willful destruction of life never bears good fruit.

But this post isn’t about despair in the face of such horror; rather it is a reflection on life, in particular on the life of a woman, a saint, whose feast we celebrate today.  She, like us, faced unprecedented horror, but she ended up its victim. Edith Stein, St. Teresa Benedicta of the Cross, faced a regime that devalued human life in a manner very similar to what we have seen in these videos.  Yet, Edith Stein’s life and death reveals beauty, hope, and a depth of self-sacrificial love in the face of absolute sorrow and horror.  Hers is a response for us to reflect upon and emulate in our own time.

Edith was born in Breslau, Germany on October 12, 1891 to Jewish parents Siegfried and Auguste Stein.  Stein’s unfinished autobiography, Life in a Jewish Family, chronicles her very normal and happy family life from her birth until 1916, which as far as she had written before the Nazis took her off to the death camps. She shows great affection for her family and friends reveals her own spiritual journey to the Church.  Edith began this book in the 1930’s as an antidote to the rising anti-Semitism in her beloved Germany. She dearly loved Germany, loved its history, loved being a Germany citizen, but she was also keenly distressed at its tempestuous political situation during WWI and in the decades the followed. Edith even took a leave of absence from her university studies during WWI to serve as a nurse for wounded soldiers. To the end, she loved her German identity.

Edith’s autobiography reveals a woman who valued relationships.  She loved her 7 older siblings and ministered to many of them in times of suffering.  She deeply cared for her friends and had a gift to understand their characters and see each of them with the utmost charity.  She deeply loved the country that would not let her work as a university professor because she was a Jew and a woman.  She loved those countrymen who, in the end, sent her and so many fellow Jews to her horrific, untimely and cruel death.  She understood with a profound clarity that all human persons depend on each other and are responsible for each other.

Edith was known as an extremely intelligent and gifted child.  She says that although her mother was quite religious and did observe the basic tenants of Judaism, Edith and her siblings were not very religious and often ridiculed their mother’s piety.  As a young teenager, Edith self-consciously decided that she did not believe in God.  It was not until she went on to receive her doctorate in philosophy that Edith would find herself attracted to the Catholic faith.

Edith studied for her doctorate under the famed professor of phenomenology, Edmund Husserl. It was also here that she began to be more open to the Christian faith, as most of her friends were Christians, both Protestant and Catholic. She was a brilliant student, and all her friends and family teased her for her great passion to study with Husserl. She writes that on one New Year’s Eve before she left to study in Goettingen for her doctorate, her sisters and friends wrote a little verse about her: “Many a maiden dreams of ‘busserl’ [kisses in German], Edith, though, of naught but Husserl. In Goettingen she soon will see Husserl as real as real can be.” (Life in a Jewish Family, p. 220).  This anecdote not only shows her passion for the intellectual pursuit of truth, but it reveals her humanness and the fondness of her friends and family.

While she was visiting a friend in 1921, she providentially found a copy of Teresa of Ávila’s autobiography. She read it in one sitting and immediately felt that the saint’s words in the book fulfilled the desires of her heart, and on January 1, 1922, Edith Stein became a Catholic.  Although her family was far from pleased by her decision, Edith remarked that they all respected her because they knew that Edith ardently sought truth with her whole being.  She was keenly aware of the impact of her conversion on those she loved.  Because her mother was so devastated by her conversion to Catholicism, Edith waited 11 years to fulfill the desire of her heart. In 1933, she entered the Carmel in Cologne, Germany.  She made her final vows in 1938, taking the name Teresa Benedicta of the Cross, which means “Teresa Blessed of the Cross” (or “Blessed by the Cross” in some translations.)

Her name reflects her beloved spiritual sister and fellow Carmelite, Teresa of Ávila, and her fate of sharing in the Cross of Christ in a very tangible, visible way.  Edith, now Teresa Benedicta of the Cross, viewed her own life as a sacrificial offering to God for her people.  In 1939, she offered her life to God for all those she loved: for the Church, for the Carmelite Order, for the Jewish people, for her family, and for “the deliverance of Germany and peace throughout the world.” (Waltraud Herbstrith, Edith Stein: A Biography. Ignatius Press, 1992, p. 162).  Rather than give in to despair, darkness, and hopelessness, Edith offered her own life and sufferings to God for others—even for those who murdered her.  She saw herself as her brothers’ keeper, and asked Our Lord to accept her life for theirs.

By 1938, the threat of the Nazis was so great in Germany that the nuns moved Edith to another Carmelite convent in Echt, Holland. It was here, as we know, that Edith and her sister Rosa were brutally taken in 1942 to their deaths in Auschwitz after the Dutch bishops took a strong stand against the Nazis. But even on the journey to her death, Edith’s great love made a lasting impression on all those who were with her.

A Jewish businessman from Cologne, Julius Markan, who had been put in charge of the prisoners at Westerbork Camp, remembers how she cared for those around her as they faced death.  He wrote:

“Amongst the prisoners who were brought in on the 5th of August, Sister Benedicta stood out on account of her calmness and composure. The distress in the barracks and the stir caused by the new arrivals were indescribable. Sister Benedicta was just like an angel, going around amongst the women, comforting them, helping them and calming them. Many of the mothers were near to distraction; they had not bothered about their children the whole day long, but just sat brooding in dumb despair. Sister Benedicta took care of the little children, washed them and combed them, attending to their feeding and other needs. During the whole of her stay there, she washed and cleaned for people, following one act of charity with another, until everyone wondered at her goodness.”

Another person who met her on the way to her death, Dr. Wielek, recalled a conversation he had with her in Westerbork just before she was transferred to Auschwitz:

“In one conversation she said to me: ‘The world is made up of opposites, but in the end nothing remains of these contrasts. What only remains is great love. How is it possible for it to be otherwise?’”

Indeed in this world, we do experience such opposites: good and evil, joy and suffering, life and death.  “What only remains is great love.”  Edith’s final conviction teaches us how to suffer, how to offer ourselves, and how to embrace a world so seemingly full of violations against the human person.  Edith shows how to live as a balm for these wounds in the world—and how such a life lived for Christ will ultimately heal it.

Edith Stein’s writings can be found in English through the Institute of Carmelite Studies.

image: © Raimond Spekking / CC BY-SA 4.0 (via Wikimedia Commons)

Angela Miceli Stout

By

Angela Miceli Stout is a visiting researcher at the University of Navarra in Pamplona Spain. She studied at Thomas More College of Liberal Arts and received a doctorate in political philosophy from Louisiana State University in 2013. She teaches ethics and political philosophy and is working on a book about Thomas Aquinas's theory of conscience. She lives in Pamplona, Spain with her husband and their son.

Subscribe to CE
(It's free)

Go to Catholic Exchange homepage

  • Pete1957

    I found some comfort in reading your article and agree love and goodness will prevail. As disciples of Christ we must love our brothers and sisters. Despite the evil being unleashed on our unborn children, there are many good people and organizations trying hard everyday to help women choose a different path, a path of love that values all life. Now more than ever we must all pick up our cross. For who else will answer the cry of the unborn?

  • ACM

    You are most welcome! I am glad this little piece has brought you some light, hope, and comfort. Get to know her! She is a magnanimous saint!

  • ACM

    Thank you, Pete1957. We pray for her intercession against such great evil.

  • William J. Walsh

    My parents have a wonderful work of art dedicated to St. Teresa Benedicta in their home. I don’t know the name for this sort of work, but it is a collection of fabrics stitched together to form a picture of Edith Stein and some scenes from her life. My mother has read her writings and has a special bond and affection for her. I should do the same. It gives one hope to hear of how she rose above her cruel and unjust fate and the evil done to her. These are the actions of a saint.
    What sort of thinker was Husserl? I’ve heard the name but do not know if he was Catholic or otherwise. I believe Martin Heidegger was originally a Catholic thinker but later stopped practicing. Did Husserl also disgrace himself by affiliating with the Nazis or was his philosophy keen enough to prevent that?
    Did the Dutch bishops do the right thing in challenging Hitler if it led to the death of converts in cloisters or, I presume, member of the clergy? I suppose there can be no simple answer to such a question.

  • Michael J. Lichens

    Hi William,

    To answer your question, Edmund Husserl was of Jewish heritage but baptized Lutheran. I don’t know that he practiced. He was also a teacher of Heidegger but the two drifted apart and Heidegger removed the dedication to Husserl in his work Being and Time when it was republished during the Nazi regime. Husserl was a victim of the race laws and couldn’t publish in Nazi Germany but died in 1938 before he could feel the full force of that wicked regime.

    You are right that Heidegger was a Catholic and was in fact introduced to philosophy by his priest. I had suspected, as an Augustinian scholar who once did grad school, that Augustine still played a big part in Heidegger’s work, and Prof Ryan Coyne has demonstrated such: http://amzn.to/1ElQpp5. However, you are right again that he rejected Catholicism, although the German philosopher admitted that it was hard for him to fully reject Christianity.

    As for the Dutch Bishops, or any person of conscience living on the Continent during that time, I agree that it’s hard to find a simple answer. I have a comfortable life, and fear that I would be cowardly. I hope examples such as Edith Stein or Maximilian Kolbe will be in my mind if I’m ever put in such a situation, but that is a hard prayer to pray.

    Thanks for your thoughtful comments and questions!

  • Linda Petote Martin

    I am a lay Carmelite, and Edith is my patron saint.
    I enjoyed this article immensely, and have shared it with my friends. Edith Stein remains an obscure and under appreciated saint, but her award-winning 1916 doctoral thesis ON THE PROBLEM OF EMPATHY was a direct contribution to JPII’s THEOLOGY OF THE BODY.
    Just a note, Edith was raised in Breslau, but born in a small town about an hour and a half away.

  • pygmallian

    The aftermath of the Dutch persecution was the reason the Pope Pius XXII largely remained silent. Yet they estimate he saved hundreds of thousands through his silent efforts. I believe the figure is close to 800,000, it is staggering. Golda Mier cried when he died. Yet in the sixties a fictional play depicted him as a Nazis lover and those who despise the Church bolstered this claim using his silence as their proof that he was an anti- semite. In spite of the overwhelming praises heaped upon him after the war by those who knew the truth The chief Rabbi of Rome at the time converted to Catholicism because of the popes efforts to rescue Jews. I think using these two examples silence was an approach that saved many lives. But the Bishops were also responsible to form the conscience of their flocks so total silence would have been wrong.

MENU