Foreclosed: Common Sense

"Let me get this straight. One reason mortgages are defaulting is because many people who should never have qualified for a loan got approved anyhow?"

"For starters."

"You're going to have to explain."

"Well, it all dates back to 9/11. We'd already been in a recession when the terrorists attacked. To keep the economy from going into a free fall, then-Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan lowered interest rates."

"Yes, I remember."

"People were suddenly able to afford houses they couldn't afford before. Home sales began to shoot up. As demand for housing rose, so did housing values."

"Go on."

"As housing values climbed, home owners saw their equity climb. Others decided owning a home was the way to easy wealth, so they began to buy, too."

"Which further drove up values?"

"Exactly. Soon, a frenzy was under way. Bidding wars were breaking out. It was common for sellers to receive multiple offers well beyond their asking price."

"That was nuts."

"That was human nature. When a big snowstorm is forecast, people rush to the store to hoard all the milk and toilet paper. The housing boom was like that."

"It never crossed people's minds that they might be overpaying for their properties?"

"Unfortunately not. It appeared to many people — even rational, well-educated people — that the rapid rise in values would never end. That caused speculators to jump into the market, which drove up values even more. It was about then that unqualified buyers jumped into the frey."

"Unqualified buyers!"

"Roughly 25 percent of Americans have a bad credit or unstable employment history. But this didn't stop loan originators from going after them, too. Mortgage brokers and banks get commissions and fees every time they originate a loan — even risky loans."

"Risky loans?"

 "Finance companies created special mortgages — subprime loans — for people who didn't qualify for the safer 'prime' loans. Because these loans come with greater risks, higher interest rates are charged — usually two or three percentage points higher. These loans are extremely profitable, as long as they are paid back."

"I still don't see how people with bad credit or unstable employment histories qualified for loans."

"The Washington Post's Steven Pearlstein explained how. Mortgage people created all kinds of nutty schemes to help all kinds of people qualify. These included interest-only mortgages, no-money-down mortgages, adjustable-rate mortgages and so on. In some cases, loan applicants didn't even have to provide proof of income."

"Didn't the mortgage people worry about loan defaults?"

"Pearlstein explains that such loans are often sold to third parties. Thus, the loan originators didn't have to worry about the risk AND they still got their commissions and fees."

"So unqualified people were given giant loans to buy over-valued houses they couldn't afford? How did they keep up with the payments?"

"As long as the buying frenzy continued, housing values kept getting pushed to even more insane heights. That allowed homeowners to either sell and cash out or borrow against their rapidly-rising equity to get the money they needed to make their monthly payments."

"They borrowed money to pay their mortgages!"

"In some cases. It was a beautiful thing while it lasted. During the past four years, $9.5 trillion in new mortgage debt has been pumped into the housing industry. That money fueled one heck of a party."

"But the party is over?"

"I'm afraid so. According to Pearlstein, the subprime mortgage market is in a melt down. He said that 1.5 million Americans may lose their homes to foreclosure. And hundreds of homes could be dumped onto a glutted market, further driving down values."

"That's not good."

"It gets worse. Consider all the jobs that depend on the housing market. Construction companies, cabinet manufacturers, furnishing companies… an endless number of industries will be hurt as the correction ripples through the economy."


"That's a term we like to use in the finance business. Translated it means: Oops, we overdid it again!'"  

Subscribe to CE
(It's free)

Go to Catholic Exchange homepage

  • Guest

    Greed.  Pure and simple.  Human's desire for more than they can afford.  Plus ignorance.  Ignorance of basic cash flow, saving/investing and market cycles.  I am far from a proponent of these underhanded morgtage schemes, but then again .. they were just giving the "consumer" what they think they wanted.  I could make the same case for automobiles …. people having to have more car than they can really afford.   Those who live by the sword .. die by the sword. 

  • Guest

    Some people have been so indulged that they just don't know how to deny themselves anything;  they're really into that instant gratification.

  • Guest

    Both dwcrago and Claire are right, but….

    Consider that you need a place to live.  Housing prices are out of sight, and rentals are worse.  What do you do?  You buy a house at an inflated price, and trust God to take care of you.  And, He does.  But, sometimes not the way you'd hoped.  One day, you are "down-sized".  You call the mortgage company and try to dicker on payments.  The mortgage co. is steadfast: pay it all, or nothing.  After 3 or 4 months, you find another job, but by now the total bill on the mortgage is more than you make in a month.  And, you still need money for gas to get to the new job, plus food, heat, etc.  What you end up with is a foreclosure.

    You can "cry poor" and become a "victim".  Or, you can view the circumstances as God calling you to move to a new area and start over.  "The Blame Game" doesn't help.  We've moved 65 miles south (closer to the new job) and started over.

  • Guest

    Make that a big "but" Cooky. Some of these folks wanted too much house and others just needed a place of their own. The mortgage game is rigged. The bank makes money on a loan and it makes money on a foreclosure. It also makes money on a bad loan based on a bad lending policy. Some people need to get burned but wouldn't it be better for the lending officer to evaluate and explain to the client what all the parameters of the transaction are? Allow me to answer my own question: No, there's no percentage in that.