Plug-Pullers Take Note: Science Finds That Some “Vegetative State” Patients are Aware

Lorina Naci

Lorina Naci

Canadian neuroscientists have detected conscious activity in a patient who has been in a “vegetative state” for 12 years using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Writing in the latest issue of JAMA Neurology, they claim that “in this study we establish for the first time that some entirely behaviorally nonresponsive patients can use selective attention to communicate”.

Lorina Naci and Adrian M. Owen of Western University, in Ontario, examined three patients who were believed to be completely unresponsive after severe brain injuries, two of them in a minimally conscious state and one in a vegetative state. They were able to “respond” by focusing their attention in a way which could be picked up with the fMRI scanner. Two of them communicated repeatedly and accurately. Many bedside assessments had completely missed their capacity for willed behaviour. (See video of Lorina Naci explaining the findings.)

“These results suggest,” they write, “that some patients who are presumed to mostly or entirely lack cognitive abilities can have coherent thoughts about the environment that surrounds them.”

The plight of patients in so-called vegetative state can be awful. Research has shown that up to 40% are misdiagnosed and actually have some degree of awareness.

In a commentary on Naci and Owen’s study, one of America’s leading neurologists, James L. Bernat, says that the data is quite convincing and “that it underscores the duty to treat them as sentient persons, to optimize their ability to communicate, and to reduce their suffering”. He writes:

“We can justifiably assume that as the level of awareness increases in a patient with a brain injury, so does his or her capacity to suffer. The patients in [minimally conscious state] discovered by fMRI studies to have been wrongly diagnosed as being in [a vegetative state] deserve our efforts to reassure them that we know they are aware, to establish a reliable communication system to the fullest extent possible, and to adequately address their medical, emotional, and palliative care needs just as we currently do with our awake and aware but profoundly paralyzed patients with [locked-in syndrome].”

 

This article originally ran at BioEdge and is used with permission

Michael Cook

By

Michael Cook likes bad puns, bushwalking and black coffee. He did a BA at Harvard University in the US where it was good for networking, but moved to Sydney where it wasn’t. He also did a PhD on an obscure corner of Australian literature. He has worked as a book editor and magazine editor and has published articles in magazines and newspapers in the US, the UK and Australia.

Subscribe to CE
(It's free)

Go to Catholic Exchange homepage

  • lightedlamp97

    As a nurse, this is a horrific thought. As a Christian, this is a reminder of the power of suffering and God’s plan for salvation. What if God permits such circumstances for the good of mankind? What if we are allowing the culture of death to overtake the salvific plan that God has in store for all of us? What happened to the first rule of medicine…Do no harm. I believe even Alzheimer’s allows families to forgive where reconciliation would have otherwise been unattainable. This is because of mercy imparted on the pitiful state of their loved ones outward being. The same could be true for the various vegetative states. How scary to be trapped inside yourself, and all the facets that would entail. Thank you for the information, this is very interesting.

MENU