Death of the Afterlife

Stephen Beale

by Stephen Beale on November 13, 2012 · 7 comments

Such issues notwithstanding, limbo remains the most compelling solution to a theological conundrum. And, while the all those who enter hell are warned to abandon hope, the Church hasn’t abandoned hope for the infants in limbo. As the Catechism states, “As regards children who have died without Baptism, the Church can only entrust them to the mercy of God, as she does in her funeral rites for them. Indeed, the great mercy of God who desires that all men should be saved, and Jesus’ tenderness toward children which caused him to say: ‘Let the children come to me, do not hinder them,’ allow us to hope that there is a way of salvation for children who have died without Baptism.”

Purgatory as Sanctification: Purgatory is traditionally defined as the place where Christians are purged of any remaining stains of sin prior to entering heaven. This completes the process of sanctification that Christians began on earth but that most, except for the saints, did not finish before their death. As with hell, this definition is correct yet it does not tell the whole story. Ultimately, the whole point of purgatory is to prepare us for the beatific vision of God. In order to understand why we need such an intense spiritual cleansing, we have to reach back to Exodus 30, where Moses asks to see “God’s glory.” God replies: “Thou canst not see my face: for man shall not see me and live.” God shows Moses mercy in sparing his life and allowing Moses to see only His back. The same principle is behind purgatory. As one Catholic blogger has written: “So great is God’s heavenly glory, that we would not be able to stand in His eternal presence if we still had ‘an unhealthy attachment to creatures’ and attachment to sin.” (It’s also worth noting that as with hell, John Paul II indicated that purgatory was more a state of being than a physical place.)

Heaven as Communion: Heaven is the one place in the afterlife most people still believe in, but they pretty much get the rest of it wrong. Aside from faithful Christians, most folks probably think of it as simply a place of eternal bliss. It is, but only because those in heaven will enjoy communion with God—what traditionally is called the “beatific vision.” This is such an awesome thing to contemplate that even Lewis shrunk back from describing it in The Great Divorce. Instead, he offers readers only a glimpse of the beatific vision from a great distance as an “unchanging sunrise”:

One dreadful glance over my shoulder I essayed—not long enough to see … the rim of the sunrise that shoots Time dead with golden arrows and puts to flight all phantasmal shapes. … The light, like solid blocks, intolerable of edge and weight, came thundering upon my head.

Lewis’ fleeting glance at the beatific vision leaves us hungering for more. May all of us nurturing such longings as we daily strive to come closer to the Light of the World.

Pages: 1 2 3

  • JMC

    I’ve always found the description of the Holy Innocents in “The Mystical City of God” by St. Mary of Agreda (translated by Fiscar Marison) to lend particular hope when we recommend the souls of unbaptized infants to the mercy of God. In one of St. Mary’s visions, Our Lady told her that God sanctified the souls of those infants (since baptism as we know it did not yet exist) so they could go directly to Heaven. I suspect that, when our newborns die without benefit of baptism, since it is through no fault of their own, God may very well act in this mysterious way to grant them access to Heaven. It also offers hope to those who are rightly concerned about the souls of aborted infants. In that same vision, St. Mary was told that God also gave those Holy Innocents the use of reason, so they could offer their sufferings to God in expiation for sin. So, even as we pray to end this heinous practice, we can hope that those unborn babies were able to offer the indescribable suffering of being literally torn from the womb, in prayer for the rest of us here on Earth.

  • rosebud

    I’ve heard from the excellent apologists on EWTN that the Church’s doctrine of “Baptism of Desire” can include the desire of the parents whose child has died without baptism. What SWEET CONSOLATION for grieving parents !

  • chaco

    I asked an agnostic; “How can you be OK with the thought of death ?” They replied; “Nothingness would be OK.” I pondered – then replied; “You can’t say that because “OK” is something – Nothing is nothing. ” If one loves life, they must necessarily be bothered by the thought of losing that something they love. Anyone who claims no concern about their mortality doesn’t love their life (suicidal) or they’re in denial. [..."By the infinite merits of His Sacred Heart & through the Immaculate Heart of Mary, we beg of you the conversion of poor sinners." (from Fatima Eucharistic prayer)]

  • http://JamesTPereira.com/ James T Pereira

    Since “limbo” is not an article of faith, please indulge my rant against it. I believe it’s a great injustice that limbo exists. How can we even believe that a just God can perpetuate such a travesty of justice.
    Limbo also indicates a God of double standards. The Catholic believes that non-Christian adults can go to heaven if they have done God’s will, without any sacraments. So how come babies who die without sacraments go elsewhere?
    We are also taught that God desires every soul to be with Him in Heaven. How can He create a soul, who will be aborted or be still-born or live-born but die before baptism and then abandoned to limbo?
    I can accept Hell but not Limbo.

  • http://JamesTPereira.com/ James T Pereira

    One more comment. If Limbo exists we couldn’t possible have the feast of Holy Innocents. None of them were baptised, since baptism came about 30 years later? Shouldn’t they all be in Limbo, instead of Heaven, since we believe Saints are in Heaven and only those in Heaven are Holy.

  • Peter Nyikos

    Why should Limbo be any more unjust than if the babies had never been conceived in the first place? The concept of limbo that I was taught was that it was a place of perfect happiness, just like heaven except that the children never had the Beatific Vision. We should all be so fortunate after we die.

    Anyway, the official position of the Catholic Church is that while we do not know the ultimate fate of unbaptized infants who die, we can be assured of God’s love and mercy towards them.

  • http://www.facebook.com/john.vondra John Vondra

    Great article- Leads to though about, Resurrection of the body-what about the bodies of those creamated and their ashes placed on a self or scattered over land or sea. For those that believe in the resurrection of the body the economics of burial is causing problems.