Benedict XVI: Ending the Counter Reformation!

Welcoming the Anglicans back to communion and permitting the retention of some of their ritual traditions should come as no surprise for Catholics that appreciate the message of Vatican II.

During the Second Vatican Council, then Father Ratzinger collaborated closely with Fr. Yves Congar (1904-1945) in revamping the Catholic view towards our Protestant brothers and sisters divided by the Reformation. Perhaps one of the most significant points of the Council to the was essentially putting an end to the Counter-Reformation prompted by the Anglican Schism and a new spirit of ecumenical understanding regarding those Christian communions. As Pope, Benedict XVI,  has consistently offered a bridge to others outside of Catholicism. Even within Catholicism itself, an olive branch extends to the liturgical extremists with the restoration of the Mass of Pope John XXIII.

Benedict’s pontificate offers an appreciation of the unique rituals and customs of Anglicanism, while allowing their coexistence with the Roman Church. It clearly illustrates that the openness towards Protestant Christianity advocated by Fr.Congar might indeed be coming to fruition. Remarkably, this gesture by Rome indicates very strongly that the Church indeed permits ritual pluralism even while it embraces theological solidarity. The notions of the modern world and the Church are quite similar in both sectors appreciating human diversity and cultural heritages. Catholics and Anglicans should really celebrate this unprecedented papal gesture towards acceptance of former Anglicans as a living expression of the concept of “E pluribus Unum.

The latest expression of reunion with the former Anglicans should be considered as the hallmark of the Benedictine papacy thus far…internal and external ecumenism. Negotiations with the extremists founded by Archbishop Lefebvre are ongoing. Relationships with the Orthodox Church have developed and there is a renewed appreciation of the cultural identity and acceptance of Islam. While the pontificate of John-Paul II strongly endorsed a new understanding of our Judaic roots, the papacy of Benedict seems to favor a more global sense of inclusion of theological plural isms. The movement might well be considered as a transcendental Thomism that brings Catholic Scholasticism into a renewed global appreciation.

The increased diplomatic and ecumenical, “reach-out,” of the Catholic Church to other faiths, cultures and traditions is part of the theological foundations of the teachings of the Second Vatican Council with the monumental document, Unitas Redintegratio (Restoration of Unity) which embraced the notions of a better appreciation and understanding of the Protestant faith. The document even suggested the Catholic Church itself could learn from their theological and cultural experiences and make great contributions to the life of the Catholic Church:

We must get to know the outlook of our separated brethren. To achieve this purpose, study is of necessity required, and this must be pursued with a sense of realism and good will. Catholics, who already have a proper grounding, need to acquire a more adequate understanding of the respective doctrines of our separated brethren, their history, their spiritual and liturgical life, their religious psychology and general background. Most valuable for this purpose are meetings of the two sides-especially for discussion of theological problems-where each can treat with the other on an equal footing-provided that those who take part in them are truly competent and have the approval of the bishops. From such dialogue will emerge still more clearly what the situation of the Catholic Church really is. In this way too the outlook of our separated brethren will be better understood, and our own belief more aptly explained — from Unitatis Redintegratio, chapter 2.

Appreciation of the things that unite us in our faiths extends also to the non-Christian members of the global community. Pope Benedict’s expressions of acceptance since taking office have included inter religious dialogues with Hindus, Buddhists, Muslims as part of the new understanding of the world order of the 21st century. The approach is refreshing: uniting theological beliefs with global human concerns. Some of the other projects undertaken by the Vatican also include involvement with scientists to solve the problem of global warming (solar panels on Paul VI Hall), providing of food and humanitarian aid to countries that lack resources and most recently papal permission to provide first aid kits to medically deficient countries. Such undertakings indeed illustrate the Catholic Church under the guidance of Benedict XVI is truly embracing its global responsibilities towards the world. What is most remarkable is the increased sense of the Church’s universal cooperation among all faiths and peoples.

Catholics really should take careful note of these renewed theological and humanitarian developments underway. The ecumenical teachings and the role of the Church in the modern world are emerging as Pope Benedict’s intention to accomplish the work he started as Father Ratzinger at Vatican II. It really seems that the hopes and intentions of aggiornamento developed by the Fathers of Vatican II are starting to sprout branches in addition to already strong historical and theological roots.

Subscribe to CE
(It's free)

Go to Catholic Exchange homepage

  • wgsullivan

    “there is a renewed appreciation of the cultural identity and acceptance of Islam.”
    Acceptance of Islam is a bit too strong for me. Appreciation of Islam I can handle.
    Acceptance of Islam infers acceptance of a denial of the Trinity and other differences. That just ain’t so.

  • Jim McFillin

    The following is troubling for what it implies:

    “Negotiations with the extremists founded by Archbishop Lefebvre are ongoing. Relationships with the Orthodox Church have developed and there is a renewed appreciation of the cultural identity and acceptance of Islam. While the pontificate of John-Paul II strongly endorsed a new understanding of our Judaic roots, the papacy of Benedict seems to favor a more global sense of inclusion of theological pluralisms.”

    First, wanting to say or attend the Tridentine (Latin) Mass does not make one an extremist. Pope Benedict XVI has authorized its use for all priests.

    Second, reaching out to people of other faiths on the one hand in an ecumenical manner should not imply that the Catholic Church is somehow accepting that their Protestant, Islamic, or Buddhist beliefs will lead them to salvation.

    Finally, Vatican II does not reverse long standing church doctrine that the Catholic Church “alone” has the fullness of salvation. “Unitatis Redintegratio” does not contradict the “ex cathedra” statements of salvation by earlier Popes, such as Innocent III, Clement V, Pius V, Eugene IV, Leo X, and Pius IX.

  • http://www.facebook.com/harry.reyhing Harry Reyhing

    Refreshing?This seems very confusing to many catholics.Where is Jesus and sharing the gospel with all those lost in these false religions?We are called first to bring the lost whether muslims,buddists,hindus etc to Jesus Christ and hopefully into the catholic church.Jesus said I am the way the truth and the life no one comes to the father but through him.For 2000 years UNTIL vatican 2 all previous popes,catholic saints,councils etc evangelized the thyen known world.We better start getting back to that as that is our true mission.Not recognizing the beauty and truth in all religions and letting the people in those false beliefs go to hell.That is not love.

MENU