Gift Giving – Santa and the Theology of the Body

December 14th, 2007 by Loretta Pioch Print This Article Print This Article ·

It is inevitable this time of year that there are questions from children surrounding the mysterious and mystical events of God made man.  But children are simple.  The reality that God can become a baby and even be born in a dirty, flea-bitten manger does not faze them when they learn that God chose to do it to save us from our sin.  It is usually the adults that complicate life. 

Take Santa Claus.  Our family tries to focus very clearly on the fact that Santa Claus is a real person — St. Nicholas.  This has helped with many a question surrounding the jolly fellow.  The North Pole?  No.  St. Nicholas does not live in the North Pole.  He lives in Heaven with Jesus.  But I guess with an operation like Christmas, there has to be a headquarters somewhere on earth.  Is Santa really able to see me right now?  Well, Jesus, who is good friends with St. Nick, can see you always.  And Mom and Dad can also talk to him in prayer.  So can you.  So how does he deliver so much on just one night?  Well, it must be a miracle of love because with Jesus, all things are possible, especially for those who love.

If it was solely up to me, I wouldn't bother with the Santa Claus theme.  We would better celebrate December 6th as St. Nicholas's feast day and gifts exchanged on the 25th would be from loving friends and family.  However, to everyone around me — and I mean everyone — from grandparents, to friends and acquaintances who come up to my children talking about Santa, to the Breakfast-with-Santa event at the parish, not to mention all the imagery surrounding us in the stores and in print, I would simply become the humbug of the season.  And I do recognize that sometimes I just need to lighten up.  Hence, I have to get creative in answering these questions that pop up every now and then.

So when I was asked a profound question (again, very simple to the young) by my oldest son, it spun me into some quite deep reflection on the gift, the giver, and the recipient.  He very simply asked me the very loaded question: Do ALL children get gifts from Santa, or do only the good ones?  I knew exactly what he was asking through that simple question.  He knows there are children out there that have not been so good during the year.  Some of them aren't even sorry for it.  Sometimes those are the ones that get the biggest, flashiest gifts from "Santa".  He also knows that he has not been perfect, although he knows that the Sacrament of Reconciliation wipes clean his slate (as long as he is truly sorry).  He is very simply trying to define in black and white terms the line between "good" and "bad" as would be applied to this "list" Santa holds.

 The reality?  All children whose families celebrate gift-giving during Christmas will receive gifts.  It doesn't matter if they have been naughty or nice.  It doesn't matter if they have been to confession or are even sorry for having done wrong.  The gifts are still given.  The children are still loved.  And what a powerful, albeit imperfect, reflection of how much God loves us.  No matter how awful we are, whether knowing or unknowing, whether repentant or not, the Gift of Jesus' sacrifice for each and every one is still offered to us.

The problem is that we cannot see the Gift with our blind eyes.  The packaging?  There is no sparkly fun paper to tear into that is adorned with ribbons and bows.  No one would pass up receiving that kind of gift.  The packaging, instead, starts with a cuddly baby.  Many people are drawn to this nice bundle.  But it quickly morphs into a Cross, blood and tears, pain and suffering adorned with a crown of thorns.  A stumbling block to the Jews and folly to Gentiles (1 Cor 1:23).  We all can stumble on this as well. 

After stumbling, we can stand again and accept this definition of a Savior.  We can even embrace that God so loved the world that He would give His one and only Son in sacrifice to save it.  The ultimate Gift to mankind.  Truly, the Gift speaks more of the Giver than of the receiver.

With this concept of gift and giver, it was fairly easy to put the question to rest.  Wouldn't it be nice to leave it as neatly packaged as that?  But we can't.  We still have to know what to do with this cross-shaped packaging.  The Gospel writers tell us that we must take up our own crosses to be able to follow Christ, or we are not worthy of Christ (Mt 10:38, Mt 16:24, Mk 8:34, Lk 9:23).  If we do not take up our own crosses, we are not worthy of the Gift.  It is still offered to us, but to receive and open up the Gift, we have to take up the Cross just like Christ.  The receiver is to become the giver. 

John Paul II wrote in his Theology of the Body about how man cannot find fulfillment unless he gives himself as a gift to another person.  Those who have received a celibate vocation, give themselves back to God as gift.  For those who have received a vocation to marriage, the gift of self is given to the spouse in imitation of the life of the Trinity.  Either way, the receiver of the Gift is to then become the giver.  This Advent, we who are married may find it necessary to reflect upon the quality of our gift to our spouses.  Remember, the gift speaks more about the giver than of the receiver.  Do we imitate Christ this way?

If we are honest with ourselves, we will surely hear the voices…

My husband doesn't talk with me like he used to!  How well do we converse with Christ each and every day?

My wife pays more attention to the kids than to me!  Do we keep Christ first in our attentions?  Or do work, social life, hobbies, distractions keep us from Him?

You just don't know what he did (or didn't do) the other day!  What have we done or didn't do according to Christ's will?

 But you should have heard what she said!  Have we said plenty to Our Lord that is nothing short of a slap in the face, an outright rejection of His desires for the best for us?

The list here is almost infinite.

Clearly, each and every one of us fails these questions at one point or another and in so many ways.  All that our own little voices do is prove that our spouses are not perfect.  We don't need our these voices to tell us that humans are frail and sinful; all we have to do is look in the mirror!  We, too, are less than perfect and have much room for improvement, especially in our relationships with God.  What do we do, then, when we turn back toward our imperfect spouses?

This brings us face to face with the Cross.  We have a choice.  Either we reject the Cross, thereby rejecting the Gift because of our self-righteousness, or we embrace the Cross and continue to make a gift of ourselves in love, in spite of our imperfect spouses.  Isn't this what Christ did?  He made a Gift of Himself to each one of us in spite of our sinfulness.  Is what any of our spouses have done to us anywhere near the magnitude of what we all have done to Christ?.  It is in embracing the weight of the Cross — the challenge of giving even when we don't feel like it — that we receive the Gift.  We must trust Jesus when He tells us that He makes this burden light. 

After all, Santa offers gifts even when children are not perfect. 

I knew you'd be wondering how on earth I could connect Santa with the Theology of the Body.  Our simple children often ask the deepest questions.  We adults complicate life when we invent unnecessary trimmings (like Santa) and when we have to answer deep questions (like those about Santa).  My life would certainly be simpler if we'd just go back to celebrating the feast of St. Nicholas.  But then, I guess I would have missed this prompting of my son to gain a deeper understanding of my own marital vocation.

Loretta Pioch, an MIT graduate with degrees in Physics and Electrical Engineering, is currently a stay-at-home raising three children. She lives in the Boston area and speaks locally on topics dealing with home and family life. She is a moderator for the CE Forums.




  • Guest

    Thank you for more ideas on how to handle Santa Claus questions if/when I become a mother!

  • Guest

    Wonderful article, Loretta. Aren't the places that our children can lead us with their questions amazing?

  • Guest

    Breakfast with Santa at the parish?

    Lord, help us!

  • Guest

    Pfmacarthur, you are so right.  I am very much enjoying the world through a child's eyes.  I hear I used to be one once, but I can't remember a thing from it.  I knew God gave me children to teach me a thing or two.  I just didn't realize he gave me children to teach me a thousand things or two.

    PTR, it does seem a bit strange at the parish.  Except that (thankfully) Santa isn't the main attraction at the event.  Families come down to have breakfast after Mass.  AND the high school kids are the ones to seat and serve the families.  It is a fabulous opportunity for high schoolers to give a gift of their time and pleasant presence.  For this, I see tremendous value. 

    But "Santa" does float among the crowds – at which point my children (I think) figured out for themselves that it isn't really Santa…just a good friend of Santa's helping him out.  And THAT is rather true.

  • Guest

    When I was in college, I once attended a Christmas Eve "children's mass" that Mrs. Claus showed up and sat at the foot of the alter and talked to children gathered around her feet. This was done in place of the homliy.

  • Guest

    I realize I am an outcast in some circles for including Saint Nicholas in Christmas as himself and not as the magic fat man who plumbs chimneys and keeps book on kiddie behavior.

    We don't do the Easter Bunny or the Tooth Fairy either. It is cute to play these schemes with small chilrden, but I distinctly remember having my heart broken as a kid when my older neighbor kids told me and, after appealilng to my parents, was "told the truth." I didn't see the point in fooling little kids then and I don't now. Christmas, Easter, and losing a tooth are special enough without embellishing them with rubbish.

    At some point, you and your children will have to sit down and talk about what you told them was true that was actually rubbish and what you told them was true that was actually true.

    Santa? Rubbish.

    Guardian Angels? True. 

    Easter Bunny? Rubbish. 

    Saints? True.

    Tooth Fairy? Rubbish.

    Real Presence in the Eucharist? True.

    Is it any wonder young people in our culture leave the faith in huge numbers once they reach the age of majority?  They go to college where professors they respect and trust tell them, "You were told rubbish growing up.  This stuff is true."

    Let's just eliminate the rubbish.

  • Guest

    Loretta, Nice article and thought-provoking.

    Protect-the-Rock, You know I never looked at any of this things that way. I have two children; the nine year old I think has figured out that Mr. Claus isn't real (she hasn't come right out and said it) and the thirteen year old I believe is holding it in so not to ruin it for her little sister. Your last two statements do have some valid points.

     

    Thanks,

    Jim

  • Guest

    I liked Loretta's article very much as well.

    As to relatives, friends, and grandparents who ask the little kiddos about Santa coming to see them?  If you have told your children the truth all along, they will reflect the truth to these well-meaning adults.

    As Loretta noted, the simple, innocent, deep, pure, and sweet questions and remarks of children often bring us out of our self-made complications to try and make things nicer and in to what is true.

    Let every heart prepare Him room…

  • Guest

    It just makes sense PTR that there have to be consequences to the lie even though it is benign. I grew up celebrating St. Nicolas on Dec. 6th and our children were also presented with the same image although it was moved to Christmas because of our culture. There are a lot of pretend games that children play so I'm not concerned about them being traumatized but I certainly would prefer the Feast day of St. Nick on the 6th. Afterall it's the origin, reason and setting for the subsequent Santa lie. It has all the proper religious overtones, while the fat red man is just secular. He brings the green to the shopping season that's why thy'll never let him go. Money talks St. Nicolas walks.

  • Guest

    When our daughter was about 6, she asked the big question right after Christmas: Is there really a Santa Claus or do you and Mommy really give me the gifts? Direct Question- Direct Answer. Well, Katie it really is Mom and Dad who do it and there isn't really a Santa. She said that was cool and went on with what she was doing. We never said another word about Santa…. almost a year goes by, it gets to be November….on her own she asks when she can write her letter to Santa and when can she go see him… She wanted to hang on to that little piece of childhood for one more year. She has grown up to be a fine woman and a holy Catholic, despite the cruel trauma of her parents deceiving her. LIGHTEN UP, PEOPLE. It is called fun and being a kid. Jack and the Beanstalk didn't happen either (sorry if that shocked you).

  • Guest

    Jim,

    I would generally have to agree with you.  I do have to be reminded to lighten up sometimes.  As I said, without this Santa thing, opportunities for deeper thought may have escaped.

  • Guest

    I believe in Santa. Just wish He would pay the bill for the toys.  While we were raising children, (there were 6) Santa would bring two big presents for each child and a lot of underware and sox.  But to a small child, Santa was the embodiment of God the Father giving love with nothing expected in return.  We opened family presents on Christmas eve.  The parish we were in didn't allow children at Midnight Mass; so when a child was old enough for the great treat of Midnight Mass, they became Santa helping to put out the toys for their younger siblings.  If santa is the embodiment of love for a 2 year old, think of how much more the love is demonstrated by a child finding he can be Santa at about the same age as he has grown in faith and love to celebrate the birth of Jesus with midnight Mass.  I threatened  but never did to move Christmas to St Nicholas feast day.

  • Guest

    On the topic of gift giving, I came across an excellent book that I think is a relevant gift for any family (including ours) that will help to celebrate Christmas the way Christians should.

    It helps us to focus on Jesus as the reason for the season. It explains several of the traditions that we practice during Christmas and also how we could create our very own family Christmas tradition (if we don't already have one).

    It has lyrics for the common Carols and even songs that we can download, recipes for the common traditional Christmas food and even some excellent gift ideas for all ages and genders.

    You definitely won't regret getting this book which won't become obsolete, therefore we can refer to it every year if needed.

    You may view the synopsis here: The Ultimate Guide to Christmas on the Net.

  • Guest

    I would agree with JimAroo also except for one insurmountable obstacle. Jack and the Beanstalk is what it always was. Not so with old Saint Nick. Since the beginning of Christianity the Church has been baptizing pagan holidays. This one has gone from its Christian inception and rich heritage of helping into indulgence and practical apostasy. So it was ours to loose and we pretty much lost it. We Christians let it be known that the world can have Santa on its own terms and we'll help with the celebrations by spending our way to happiness. Other than that Santa doesn't faze me one bit.

  • Guest

    There is the other inevitable question: "Why doesn't Santa bring presents to everyone"? As the season includes charitable giving many people provided toys for chairites like  Angel Tree, Toys for Tots, or the boxes for Samaritin's Purse. Our children notice, then wonder why Santa and his elves need help. If St. Nick were "The Man", all of the giving and receiving of gifts would mean so much more with St. Nick rather than Santa.

     

    "The Catholic Church frames the Christian life as one in which you must exercise virtue—not because virtue saves you, but because that's the way God's grace gets manifested." Dr. Francis J. Beckwith

  • Guest

    Jimaroo,

    As I said, I am an outcast in some circles. I'm happy your daughter is a devout Catholic.  So am I, and I trust our children will grow into faithful Catholics without Santa.

    I was not asserting an immutable law about sorting through the rubbish from the truth and so many young adults walking away from the faith.  All I am saying is Christmas is filled with wonder and awe without the fat burglar; Easter is full of joy and excitement without the giant rodent; losing a tooth is special and celebrated without a fairy burglar.  Our children do play make believe games and we do tell stories.  We just don't take them at a tender trusting age and fib to them about rubbish we will have to admit was a fib later on.

    The traditions and customs of the truth are abundant. They work.

    PTR 

    PS Are you certain about the beanstalk thing?  Think about kudzu. (smile)